Resilience or Rupture: Pakistan’s ESG Gamble in an Era of Compounding Crises

1. ESG in the Shadow of Instability

Pakistan is no stranger to polycrisis. In the space of a few years, it has faced record-breaking floods, fiscal insolvency, political upheaval, and a sovereign debt scare. Yet amid the turbulence, a quieter transformation is taking shape: a nascent but accelerating ESG agenda.

Historically seen as a laggard on sustainability, Pakistan is beginning to realize that ESG integration is no longer optional—it is a strategic necessity. From the urgent threat of climate change to youth unemployment and energy insecurity, the country’s existential challenges are ESG challenges in disguise.

But progress is uneven. While climate policy has gained international visibility, social indicators remain fragile, governance reforms are inconsistent, and green finance is still embryonic. With external debt over 70% of GDP, Pakistan’s ability to finance a just transition will depend on strategic partnerships, fiscal innovation, and institutional credibility.

2. Environmental Pressures: Between Floods and Fossil Fuels

2.1 Climate Vulnerability and Global Attention

Pakistan ranks 8th on the Global Climate Risk Index (Germanwatch, 2023), despite contributing less than 1% of global emissions. The 2022 floods submerged nearly a third of the country, affecting 33 million people and causing $30 billion in losses.

The disaster catalyzed global sympathy and led to:

• The creation of the Loss and Damage Fund at COP27.

• Renewed pledges from multilateral donors and climate funds.

• A push for climate adaptation financing, particularly for water, agriculture, and disaster resilience.

  
  

2.2 Policy Response and Energy Transition

The government has pledged net-zero emissions by 2050, with interim goals including:

• 60% renewable energy share by 2030

• 30% electric vehicle share by 2030

• A moratorium on new coal-fired power plants (except those already under construction)

  
  

Yet contradictions persist:

• Pakistan still imports $17 billion in fossil fuels annually, worsening its current account.

• Hydropower dependence (~30% of generation) raises concerns about water stress and displacement.

• The Alternative and Renewable Energy Policy 2019 remains under-implemented due to financing and grid limitations.

  
  

3. Social Equity: The Weakest Link in ESG

3.1 Youth, Gender, and Informality

Pakistan is one of the youngest countries in Asia, with over 64% under age 30. Yet:

• Youth unemployment exceeds 15%, with even higher rates among university graduates.

• Over 70% of women are excluded from the formal labor force.

• Informal employment accounts for 72% of the non-agricultural workforce, limiting access to labor protections and social benefits.

  
  

3.2 Education and Health Gaps

Social indicators remain troubling:

• 22.8 million children are out of school (UNICEF, 2023).

• Stunting affects 38% of children under five.

• Public health spending remains below 1.2% of GDP, far below WHO recommendations.

  
  

These indicators translate to a low Social Impact Integrated Score (SIIS) — estimated at 42.6 out of 100, signaling weak institutional capacity for social progress.

4. Governance: Reforming Under Fire

4.1 Regulatory Evolution

Pakistan’s ESG governance architecture is maturing, albeit slowly:

• The Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) introduced ESG disclosure guidelines for listed companies in 2022.

• The State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) has mandated green banking principles, including risk assessments and green lending targets.

• The Pakistan Stock Exchange launched a Sustainability Index (PSX-SI) in 2023, listing top ESG-compliant firms.

Yet enforcement remains weak:

• Only 15% of listed companies currently provide ESG-aligned reporting.

• Corporate governance scandals, such as in the energy and real estate sectors, continue to erode investor confidence.

4.2 Rule of Law and Corruption

Pakistan ranks 133 out of 180 on the Transparency International Corruption Perceptions Index (2023), indicating persistent issues with:

• Procurement irregularities

• Weak judicial enforcement

• Regulatory capture in state-owned enterprises

  
  

These governance gaps raise the cost of capital, discourage ESG investors, and undermine the credibility of sustainability commitments.

5. Finance: Green Shoots in a Brown Economy

5.1 Green Bonds and Climate Finance

Pakistan made its debut in sustainable finance with:

• The launch of a $500 million green Eurobond in 2021 (Ministry of Finance).

• The issuance of Islamic green sukuk for renewable energy projects.

• Engagement with Green Climate Fund (GCF) and Adaptation Fund, though disbursement remains slow.

• 
  

Yet green finance remains marginal:

• Less than 2% of total bank lending is directed toward sustainable sectors.

• No national taxonomy exists to define and verify green assets, though the SBP has announced plans to develop one by 2025.

  
  

5.2 ESG Investment and Private Sector Readiness

• Impact investing remains nascent, concentrated in a few urban hubs like Karachi and Lahore.

• Startups in ESG tech and clean energy face barriers in scaling due to regulatory uncertainty and limited venture capital.

• Microfinance and Islamic banking are seen as potential tools for inclusive ESG finance, especially in rural areas.

  
  

6. Geopolitical and Trade Dimensions

6.1 ESG and Export Competitiveness

As the EU and other markets move towards carbon border adjustments (CBAM) and stricter due diligence laws, Pakistani exporters will face:

• Pressure to decarbonize textile and leather supply chains.

• Traceability requirements for goods entering European markets.

• Potential tariff penalties if ESG compliance remains weak.

  
  

Pakistan’s largest export sector—textiles, worth over $20 billion—is carbon- and water-intensive, yet only a fraction of firms are certified or ESG-compliant.

6.2 ESG and International Partnerships

Pakistan’s ESG diplomacy includes:

• Participation in the Global Shield against Climate Risks, launched by the G7.

• Engagement with the China–Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) Phase II for green industrial zones.

• MoUs with Germany, the UK, and the UNDP on climate resilience and just transition frameworks.

  
  

7. Challenges: ESG Under Pressure

7.1 Fiscal Space and Sovereign Risk

• Pakistan’s debt-to-GDP ratio exceeds 70%, with debt servicing consuming half the federal budget.

• The country is under an IMF Extended Fund Facility, limiting discretionary spending and ESG investment.

• Subsidy reforms (e.g., energy and agriculture) needed for ESG alignment are politically toxic.

  
  

7.2 Political Volatility

• Frequent cabinet reshuffles and provincial-federal conflicts delay ESG implementation.

• Policy continuity is rare, with climate and energy portfolios reshuffled multiple times since 2020.

  
  

7.3 ESG Literacy and Public Perception

• ESG remains an elite-driven discourse; grassroots awareness is limited.

• Misinformation and skepticism around carbon taxes and green regulations are common.

• Civil society engagement is fragmented, though growing among youth and climate activists.

8. Recommendations: Building an ESG-Resilient Pakistan

8.1 Establish a National ESG Framework

• Develop a Pakistan ESG Strategy 2030, harmonizing environmental, social, and governance targets.

• Create a central ESG council under the Ministry of Planning to coordinate across sectors.

  
  

8.2 Expand Green and Inclusive Finance

• Launch a national green taxonomy and blended finance platform for public-private ESG investment.

• Incentivize banks to offer sustainability-linked loans, especially for SMEs and agribusiness.

  
  

8.3 Strengthen ESG Data and Transparency

• Mandate ESG disclosures for all listed companies by 2026.

• Build a national ESG data portal to support investors, regulators, and civil society.

  
  

8.4 Prioritize Social Metrics

• Integrate SIIS indicators into government budgeting, procurement, and development planning.

• Link ESG finance to measurable social outcomes—education, gender parity, and labor rights.

  
  

9. Conclusion: A Fragile but Vital ESG Frontier

Pakistan is not yet an ESG leader—but it is becoming an ESG laboratory. The country’s high vulnerability, youthful population, and reform potential make it a critical case study in sustainability under stress.

The road ahead is steep. But if Pakistan can align its ESG ambitions with fiscal realism, institutional reform, and inclusive policy design, it may not just survive the 21st century’s crises—but help define its solutions.